Ready for another recipe straight from my childhood? These No Bake Cookies were a go-to for a chocolate fix year-round. But we always made them at Christmastime. Not only do they make a quick and easy addition to the holiday treat smorgasbord, these cookies are also one of my brother’s favorites.
Of course, the original no bake cookies we made were full of cane sugar and oatmeal. So I asked my mom for a copy of the recipe we used growing up and paleo-ified it.
Honestly, the recipe we used as kids surprised me.
I could have sworn our recipe used chocolate chips, but it turns out the chocolate mixture is made entirely from scratch. Unfortunately, it also involves a couple ingredients I wouldn’t dare touch anymore: margarine and the mysterious “syrup” (which I can only assume in corn syrup).
Luckily, even though the ingredient list seems long, these no bake cookies only require a few minutes of active kitchen time. There’s a reason these were a go-to at our house! Often, we skipped actually making cookies and instead simply ate heaping spoonfuls of the mixture out of the pot, each armed with our own spoon. Ah, the memories.
When I told my mom I wanted the recipe so I could make a version for the blog, she made sure to let me know that her recipe originally comes from her grandma’s kitchen. My grandma then altered that recipe slightly to suit her tastes and the tastes of her 10 kids. Once my brother, the first grandson, was born, these cookies were quickly labeled his favorite.
And I altered the recipe again. The changes are pretty basic, honestly. Sugar becomes coconut sugar. Milk becomes coconut milk. Oatmeal becomes coconut…and so on. I also halved the recipe, so this makes about two dozen cookies rather than a massive four dozen batch.
When I made them, I toasted the coconut and pecans. But technically, that means they aren’t “no bake” cookies anymore since you’re using the oven. So…toast if you wish! Toasted coconut/pecans will make for a crunchier cookie. Not toasting makes a chewy cookie. Also, if nuts aren’t your thing, feel free to use additional coconut flakes in place of pecans. Either way, this recipe is quick and satisfying. Enjoy!
Paleo No Bake Cookies